Tominaga, G. T., K. L. Staudenmayer, S. Shafi, K. M. Schuster, S. A. Savage, S. Ross, P. Muskat, N. T. Mowery, P. Miller, K. Inaba, M. J. Cohen, D. Ciesla, C. V. Brown, S. Agarwal, M. B. Aboutanos, G. H. Utter and M. Crandall (2016). “The american association for the surgery of trauma grading scale for 16 emergency general surgery conditions: Disease-specific criteria characterizing anatomic severity grading.” J Trauma Acute Care Surg 81(3): 593-602.
Full text of this article.
The concepts for the EGS grading scales were modeled loosely from cancer staging criteria and trauma organ injury scales. For each of EGS diseases, the descriptions and grade were specifically defined using findings derived from four distinct categories: (1) clinical, (2) imaging, (3) operative, and (4) pathologic. These categories were selected to create the most holistic picture of the disease process. Furthermore, it was recognized that not all EGS conditions would require operative intervention, so the grading system could not rely solely on operative or pathologic findings. In cases where the grade differed between the four categories, the highest grade of EGS disease would apply. For example, if the computed tomography (CT) scan shows evidence of acute gangrenous appendicitis without perforation (Grade 2) but the pathologic findings are transmural necrosis with perforation (Grade 3), then the patient would be classified as Grade 3. Definitions were derived after examination of existing grading systems, review of the literature, and expert opinion. Previously reported scoring systems for these 16 EGS diseases were reviewed. No anatomic disease grading scales were found for breast abscess, intestinal obstruction, infectious colitis, pelvic inflammatory disease, and pleural space infections. Diagnostic imaging (CT, magnetic resonance imaging [MRI], ultrasound, endoscopic, nuclear medicine scan) descriptions based on disease severity have been published for acute cholecystitis,18–20 acute diverticulitis,9,10,21,22 esophageal perforation,23 acute pancreatitis,24–26 pelvic inflammatory disease,27 perforated peptic ulcer,28 and perirectal abscess.29 These were reviewed and incorporated into our data dictionary for these disease processes where applicable. Proposed EGS disease data dictionaries for each grade of disease were then carefully reviewed and revised until a consensus was achieved.